Leclerc Five-Second Penalty Divides Fans at Mexico City GP

Leclerc Five-Second Penalty Divides Fans at Mexico City GP
Charles Leclerc and Lewis Hamilton in action during the Mexico City Grand Prix. Photo: Yuri Cortez / AFP via Getty Images

MEXICO CITY — Charles Leclerc's five-second penalty at the Mexico City Grand Prix has divided Formula 1 fans, with some arguing it was far too lenient while others insist he should not have been punished at all. The Ferrari driver went around the outside of polesitter and team-mate Lewis Hamilton at Turn 4 on the opening lap, with both cars leaving the track before Leclerc emerged ahead of the pack after cutting the corner.

After deliberation, the stewards handed Leclerc a five-second time penalty for leaving the track and gaining an advantage, by which time he had already built a gap in clean air — a significant benefit in Mexico. Hamilton was unimpressed on team radio: “The problem with the 5 second penalty is he’s got clean air. He doesn’t have to manage like the rest of us. He should just give the position back." Max Verstappen, who had moved up to second, replied: “Ha! I thought all the new penalties were 10?”

Many supporters sided with Hamilton and Verstappen. One user on X wrote that Leclerc could “gallop off into the lead while the FIA take 12 laps to make their mind up”, while another posted: “5 second penalty for Leclerc. Deserved more.” A third added: “Five second penalty is not enough when Leclerc is already 3.5 sec over Verstappen and 5+ over Hamilton, and has benefit of clear air which is huge here.” Broadcaster Tom Gaymor said: “Charles knew exactly what he was doing there, braked to be ahead at the apex not to make the corner, clearly gains an advantage and let’s stewards argue it out, has clean air and has not lost a place, worst case scenario 5 secs pen!”

Plenty of others felt Leclerc had been harshly treated and blamed Hamilton’s defence instead. “5S PENALTY IS A JOKE, PENALISE HAMILTON AS WELL BECAUSE IF HE DOESN’T PUSH HIM OUT HE ACTUALLY MAKES THE CORNER,” one fan wrote. F1 journalist Thomas Maher said: “I don’t think either Ferrari driver merits any slap from the stewards for that. Hamilton tried to brazen it out, but Leclerc was on the outside and can’t disappear." The clash came after Hamilton's first Ferrari pole in Mexico qualifying, with one balanced verdict summing it up as “very aggressive attack by Leclerc, very aggressive defense by Lewis.”