Premier League Panel Finds Joint-Record Six Referee Errors

Premier League Panel Finds Joint-Record Six Referee Errors
Arsenal's Kai Havertz in discussion with the referee during the match. Photo: Getty Images

LONDON — The Premier League's Key Match Incidents Panel has ruled there were six on-field errors in the last round of fixtures, the joint-highest total it has recorded in one weekend. The five-member panel assess all contentious incidents each week, and vote separately on the referee and the video assistant referee. You have to go back to the early part of the 2023-24 season to find the last time six mistakes were logged.

The panel ruled unanimously that both the referee and VAR were incorrect over two missed interventions. Coventry City's Caleb Yirenkyi appeared to have his hair pulled inside the area by Everton's James Tarkowski, with no penalty awarded. "Tarkowski had a hold of Yirenkyi's hair and the panel unanimously felt that VAR should have intervened." Arsenal were also denied a penalty when Kai Havertz was pulled down inside the area by Hull City's Nobel Mendy, after VAR Michael Oliver sent referee Farai Hallam to the pitchside monitor but it was not given for offside.

Four further on-field errors were identified where the panel backed VAR not to intervene because of the high bar. Thierno Barry put Everton in front against Coventry in the 61st minute amid a handball check, voted 2:3 incorrect on the field but 5:0 for no VAR intervention. Crystal Palace were awarded a penalty against Liverpool three minutes into stoppage time for a foul by Milos Kerkez on Dario Osorio, voted 0:5 incorrect on the field but 5:0 for no intervention. Ipswich Town were awarded a 72nd-minute penalty against Bournemouth for a foul by Lewis Cook on Abdoul Ouattara, voted 1:4 incorrect, while Bournemouth's Marcus Tavernier escaped a second yellow card for delaying the restart, voted 2:3 incorrect.

Several other high-profile flashpoints were judged correct on the field and by VAR. Leeds United's Jayden Bogle, the subject of a Tottenham complaint after catching Mathys Tel on the ankle, was voted 3:2 correct with no red card. Chelsea's Cole Palmer going down under Sunderland's Luke O'Nien was voted 4:1 correct as a free-kick outside the area, while Sunderland's penalty when Levi Colwill was ruled to have tripped Brian Bobbey was voted 5:0 correct. The figures do not include correct VAR interventions to fix errors, such as the red card shown to Brentford's Igor Thiago.

When voting there are two separate considerations, the referee's basic judgement in law and the Premier League's expected interpretation, and the potential VAR intervention. The latter takes into account what the referee has said, the available replay angles and the high bar for intervention. Only two were ruled missed VAR interventions, with six missed overall, the same number as this stage last season. The KMI Panel was scrapped this summer in the Scottish Premiership because clubs became frustrated with the voting patterns of its members.