Rassie Erasmus Six-Match Ban Splits Rugby World Apart

Rassie Erasmus Six-Match Ban Splits Rugby World Apart
South Africa head coach Rassie Erasmus looks on during a training session. Photo: BBC Sport

LONDON — Rassie Erasmus has divided rugby after being handed a six-match ban for a scattergun series of complaints about officiating that included a suggestion of match-fixing against his South Africa side. World Rugby ruled his comments attacked the credibility of match officials, yet in his homeland they have rushed to his defence.

Erasmus took the South Africa job in March 2018 after the departure of Allister Coetzee, when South Africa were ranked sixth in the world. They arrived off a November tour in which they lost to Wales and were thrashed 38-3 by Ireland, a few months after New Zealand had racked up a record 57-0 win. "Rassie was just asking questions," said former South Africa hooker Hanyani Shimange. "But you have to look at the facts. Where was the accountability for that refereeing performance?" Legendary fly-half Naas Botha called the punishment a "debacle", adding: "You can't tell me they [officials] are untouchable."

South Africa's number 13 is tackled by France defenders during the international match.
South Africa's number 13 is tackled by France defenders during the international match. Photo: BBC Sport

His record since is astonishing. South Africa won the 2019 World Cup and defended their title in 2023, and will go into the 2027 tournament aiming for an unprecedented three-peat. Long before the sport's data revolution, he was coding match footage after picking up the technique from a friend who worked in the military, later developing Outfox, his own software which allows his teams to run through moves virtually away from the pitch. He pioneered forward-heavy replacement benches, saw the potential of diminutive Sevens specialist Kurt-Lee Arendse and moulded Andre Esterhuizen into a genuine hybrid player capable of playing in the back row and the backline. Trick plays - forcing a scrum with a deliberate infringement off kick-off, or setting up a line-out in the middle of the pitch - have been part of his arsenal, alongside exploiting every loophole, from swapping his starting front row just over an hour before kick-off against France last weekend under Nations Championship regulations to demoting himself to water boy to run the touchline during the 2021 series win over the British and Irish Lions.

"He is one of the master tacticians the game has ever seen," former Springbok wing Brian Habana, who worked under Erasmus at the Stormers, told BBC Sport's Ireland Rugby Social. "I don't always agree with how Rassie comes across, but I understand he wears his heart on his sleeve. He has got incredibly high standards. He's willing to be in the firing line to defend what he believes is right." In July, World Rugby introduced new rules targeting "comments which, viewed objectively, a reasonable person would conclude were an attack on the credibility or competence of the match officials". Given his previous, including an hour-long monologue bemoaning officiating of a first-Test defeat by the Lions in 2021 and tweets after a loss to France a year later, he may be fortunate to receive only six matches. "Robust, respectful debate is natural, but teams have access to well-established and supported channels and protocols for raising officiating matters before and after matches," World Rugby said. "Challenging a decision is not the same as questioning an official's integrity or making comments that expose them to personal abuse."

For many South Africans, though, Erasmus remains an outlaw hero and World Rugby, based in Dublin, is seen as tilted towards the north. Australian Brett Robinson, the current chairman, is the first figure from outside the Six Nations countries to hold the organisation's top job since it became an elected position. The World Cup has been lifted by South Africa on four occasions, but held there only once, while Japan coach Eddie Jones recently suggested Ireland's political clout was behind his team's home fixture being staged in Australia rather than Tokyo. South Africa were a powerful voice against possible moves to "depower" the scrum at a February conference on future law tweaks. Whether Erasmus courts controversy deliberately is hard to tell, and his offences have also come in his second language as an Afrikaans speaker. "He also has almost no filters, so he will speak his mind without fully appreciating the consequences of what he has done," his biographer David O'Sullivan told BBC Sport in 2023. Referees Nic Berry and Wayne Barnes have been previous targets, and France's win over South Africa was only the Springboks' third defeat in 11 matches this year.